Ms. Nguyen Minh Hoa is a teacher at a private primary school in Ha Dong district (Hanoi). Her and her husband's monthly income is less than 40 million VND. Their personal income tax deduction is 22 million VND and 8.8 million VND for dependents for their two children.
Thus, with a taxable income of VND9.2 million per month, they have to pay about VND460,000 in personal income tax, equivalent to VND5.5 million per year. This is not a small amount of money in the context of increasing living costs.
"Paying taxes is the responsibility of the people, but the cost of living has increased many times while income remains the same, and taxes have not been reduced at all," said Ms. Hoa, adding that she has to save on every expense to ensure living expenses for her family of four.
Ms. Hoa is one of more than 26 million salaried workers who pay personal income tax, as of the end of 2023. According to regulations, they are deducted for social insurance, health insurance, unemployment insurance and family allowances... the remaining amount is taxable income.
Personal deduction of 11 million VND per month maintained from 2020, determined by the tax authority as "the spending level to meet the minimum living needs of a person". The deduction for dependents is 4.4 million VND.
For salaried taxpayers like Ms. Hoa, the family deduction is the basis for determining personal taxable income. However, the taxable starting point and family deduction - the basis for calculating income tax - have only changed twice in the past 16 years. The most recent adjustment was made by the authorities in July 2020, more than 4 years ago, while people's income, spending, prices and inflation have increased every year.
"The Personal Income Tax Law needs to be amended in 2025, to take effect from the beginning of 2026," said Dr. Nguyen Quoc Viet, Deputy Director of the Vietnam Institute for Economic and Policy Research (VEPR, Vietnam National University, Hanoi), adding that the operator "should not be rigid in following the roadmap of submitting it to the National Assembly by the end of 2025 and approving it by mid-2026."
If 2007 is taken as the base year - the time when the Personal Income Tax Law was enacted, people's spending and income have increased many times compared to the growth rate of family deductions. Specifically, in 2008, the time the Personal Income Tax Law took effect, each person spent an average of about 792,000 VND.
In 2022, this figure will increase 3.5 times to nearly 2.8 million VND, according to a survey by the General Statistics Office (GSO) with nearly 47,000 households in communes and wards representing the whole country. While the spending level of each person is 4-5 times higher than in 2008, the minimum wage has increased 6-7 times, but the family deduction is less than 3 times.
However, according to a reporter survey conducted with more than 23,900 readers with an average income of 22 million VND per month, taxpayers spend more than 10 million VND on themselves but they spend at least 7 million VND to support a dependent. This level accounts for 70% of personal expenses, larger than the 40% rate determined by the Ministry of Finance.
The size of the economy is 430 billion USD, as of the end of 2023. Average income per capita is nearly 102 million VND/person/year, more than 7.5 times higher than in 2007. Essential goods and services also increase in price steadily every year, many types "adjust faster than income". For example, according to the General Statistics Office, education increased by 17%, food increased by 27%, gasoline prices increased by 105% compared to 2020.
In this round of consultation on the law amendment, the Ministry of Finance proposed to study the option of having the Government regulate the family deduction level. This will make the policy flexible, suitable for reality and create consensus from the people.
According to Mr. Nguyen Quoc Viet, family deductions must be based on the actual living standards of each region, and can be based on the regional minimum wage. Suppose the family deduction is 4 times the regional minimum wage. The minimum wage in Ho Chi Minh City is 4.96 million VND, so the family deduction is about 19.84 million VND, instead of 11 million VND per month as at present.
Regarding the family deduction based on the regional minimum wage, according to lawyer Nguyen Duc Nghia, Deputy Director of the Center for Supporting Small and Medium Enterprises (Ho Chi Minh City Business Association), the Government will not need to adjust it every year. Because the salary is set annually based on the agreement between representatives of workers, employers and business associations.
According to lawyer Truong Thanh Duc, Director of ANVI Law Firm, the family deduction level should be adjusted accordingly to the increase and decrease of CPI data announced by the General Statistics Office at the end of the year. "Such a regulation will not be outdated or disadvantageous to taxpayers," he said.
Family deduction is the amount of expenses to ensure the minimum living needs of the taxpayer and their dependents (parents, children). This amount is adjusted when the CPI fluctuates more than 20% compared to the time the law took effect - 2008.
To reduce family allowances in line with people's actual spending and salary, lawyer Nguyen Van Duoc, member of the Executive Committee of the Vietnam Tax Consultants Association, said that the Government should make adjustments when the CPI fluctuates by 5-10%.
For dependents, lawyer Nghia suggested that the deduction threshold should be equal to 50% of the taxpayer's level, higher than the current rate of 40%. Correspondingly, this level is about VND9.92 million per month, instead of the current VND4.4 million.
In addition, experts also recommend not counting reasonable expenses such as medical expenses, education expenses or interest on mortgage loans... in taxable income. Lawyer Nguyen Van Duoc, member of the Executive Committee of the Vietnam Tax Consulting Association, commented that these are essential expenses, accounting for a large proportion of the spending structure of households. "These expenses have also increased sharply, but are not deducted before calculating taxes, which is a shortcoming that needs to be corrected," he said.
| Tax level | Taxable income (million VND) | Tax rate (%) |
| 1 | Up to 5 | 5 |
| 2 | Over 5-10 | 10 |
| 3 | Over 10-18 | 15 |
| 4 | Over 18-32 | 20 |
| 5 | Over 32-52 | 25 |
| 6 | Over 52-80 | 30 |
| 7 | Over 80 | 35 |
In addition to family deductions, the thick tax schedule and the accumulation of taxes right at the first income steps are also shortcomings that need to be changed, according to VEPR Deputy Director Nguyen Quoc Viet.
The progressive tax rate for salaried employees currently consists of 7 levels, with tax rates ranging from 5% to 35%. Mr. Viet proposed reducing it to 5 levels and widening the gap between tax rates.
More specifically, ANVI Law Firm Director Truong Thanh Duc said the tax rate for level 1 should be reduced to about 1-2%; the highest level is 20%. "There is no reason for the personal income tax at level 7 to be currently 35%, almost double the corporate income tax," Duc said.
Not to mention, according to Mr. Viet, this helps taxpayers at the first level, especially young workers, have the conditions to accumulate income to invest in improving their own capacity and stabilizing their lives.
"This is a necessary change in the context of increasingly expensive housing prices and service costs directly related to people's lives in big cities," Mr. Viet acknowledged.
This view is also recognized by the authorities. The Ministry of Finance is proposing to adjust the progressive tax schedule in part by reducing the number of levels and widening the income gap. This is to ensure regulation for high-income earners, making it easier to declare and pay taxes.
TB (according to VnExpress)Source: https://baohaiduong.vn/de-xuat-sua-thue-thu-nhap-ca-nhan-ngay-nam-2025-399487.html
Comment (0)