The outstanding performance of the competition night of the live show 2 Our Song Vietnam was the combination of the trio Ngoc Anh - Hoang Hai - Phan Duy Anh with the song Rieng mot goc troi by musician Ngo Thuy Mien.
Completely different from the original, Rieng mot goc troi at the show was remixed in a fiery rock symphony style. Three skilled voices compete in high notes on a violin background combined with strings. In particular, Hoang Hai and the impressive opera section create a majestic and unique sound.
The trio Hoang Hai - Ngoc Anh - Phan Duy Anh sing "Rieng mot goc troi". Video: Dong Tay Promotion.
MC Tran Thanh praised the trio, commenting that it had been a long time since he heard a new version with such a strong spirit.
To get a satisfactory arrangement, different from the old song as required by the program, Hoang Hai shared that the artists had to stay up all night, go to musician Khac Hung's practice room to record and practice. Hoang Hai recorded the opera part 6 times to complete it. With Ngoc Anh, she discussed with Khac Hung to build a singing style similar to the classic rock song The Phantom of the Opera .
The reworking of Tuan Ngoc's hit in a rock style has created controversial opinions. Those who love the quiet and sentimental will find it difficult to accept the new look of Rieng mot goc troi .
“Ruining the emotional song”, “Tired of listening, wanting to stop breathing”, “Ruining the song without any emotion”, “There are songs that should keep the soulful melody instead of mixing it with rock, losing the inherent emotion”… some opinions criticize the new mixing style of Rieng mot goc troi.
On the contrary, many audiences enjoyed the way Hoang Hai and Phan Duy Anh handled the song and reached a high range. For a singing and performance competition, the climax, drama, and bringing a new spirit are necessary, and it is impossible to sing the original version exactly.
“Personally, I think the singers of the new version did well in terms of technique, soulful and passionate. The criteria of the contest is to create songs in a new style, we cannot ask them to sing like Tuan Ngoc”, “The rock & symphony harmony is pleasing to the ear, climaxing and heroic. Hoang Hai's opera part is very passionate, Ngoc Anh has a strong voice, a solid breath”, "Phan Duy Anh is not inferior to his seniors"… the audience welcomed the spirit of the rock-inspired music.
Rieng mot goc troi is Tuan Ngoc’s own “brand” when singing lyrical music. He once shared the song as fate, luck in his singing career. The famous singer sang many works by musician Ngo Thuy Mien, but Rieng mot goc troi is a special case, loved by the public for a long time and persistently.
Source: https://danviet.vn/ca-khuc-rieng-mot-goc-troi-cua-tuan-ngoc-bi-pha-nat-20241009144024481.htm
Comment (0)